Moving to Lancaster, PA: Pros, Cons, Cost of Living & Best Places to Live

Moving to Lancaster, PA: Pros, Cons, and Everything You Need to Know

Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is an increasingly popular destination for those looking to relocate, thanks to its rich history, vibrant arts scene, affordability, and growing economy. Whether you're moving for work, lifestyle, or a fresh start, this guide will help you weigh the pros and cons, explore frequently asked questions, and gain insights into what makes Lancaster a great place to live.

Pros of Moving to Lancaster, PA

1. Affordability

• Compared to major cities like Philadelphia and New York, Lancaster offers significantly more affordable housing and cost of living.

• The median home price in Lancaster County is around $290,000, which is lower than the national median of approximately $400,000.

• Rental prices are also more budget-friendly, with a typical one-bedroom apartment averaging $1,200 per month in Lancaster City and around $1,000 in suburban areas.

• The overall cost of living is 7-10% lower than the national average, making it a great place for homeownership and financial stability.

2. Thriving Economy and Business Growth

• Lancaster has a strong job market, with top employers in healthcare, manufacturing, and education.

• Major employers in the region include Penn Medicine Lancaster General Health, Armstrong World Industries, Turkey Hill Dairy, Clark Associates, Masonic Village, and Fulton Financial Corporation.

• The average household income in Lancaster County is approximately $73,000, while the median individual salary is around $45,000.

• The city also has a growing entrepreneurial scene, with an increasing number of tech startups and locally owned businesses.

3. Cultural and Entertainment Scene

• Theatre & Arts: The Fulton Theatre, the country's oldest continuously operating theatre, offers Broadway-quality productions. Other prominent theatres include Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre, Prima Theatre, and The Ware Center.

• Entertainment: Lancaster offers farmers markets, live music venues, and seasonal festivals such as Lancaster Roots & Blues Festival and Lititz Fire & Ice Festival.

• Outdoor Activities: The county boasts scenic hiking trails like Chickies Rock Park, Susquehannock State Park, and Lancaster County Central Park.

4. Fantastic Food Scene

• The city is a foodie’s paradise with a mix of farm-to-table restaurants, authentic international cuisine, and classic Pennsylvania Dutch food.

• Popular dining spots include:

  • Lancaster Central Market – The country’s oldest farmers market with diverse food vendors.

  • Luca – Upscale Italian cuisine with wood-fired pizzas and fresh pasta.

  • The Belvedere Inn – A fine-dining restaurant featuring contemporary American cuisine and live jazz music.

  • Cork & Cap – A cozy spot for comfort food, steak, and seafood.

  • Citronnelle – A French-inspired bistro with a modern twist.

5. Family-Friendly and Safe

• Lancaster is known for its close-knit communities, excellent schools, and a variety of family-friendly activities.

• Dutch Wonderland, a popular amusement park for kids, offers a fun and affordable day trip with tickets averaging $45 per person.

• The area has numerous parks, playgrounds, and recreational facilities.

• Crime rates are lower than in larger urban areas, and many neighborhoods offer a welcoming, small-town feel.

Cons of Moving to Lancaster, PA

1. Traffic and Transportation Limitations

• While Lancaster has a public bus system (Red Rose Transit), it lacks major public transportation options like a subway or commuter rail, making a car almost essential.

• Some areas experience traffic congestion, especially during peak tourism seasons.

2. Seasonal Weather

• Winters can be cold and snowy, with temperatures dipping to 20°F (-6°C), while summers can be hot and humid, reaching 90°F (32°C).

• If you’re not a fan of seasonal extremes, this might be a drawback.

3. Limited Big City Amenities

• While Lancaster offers many conveniences, it doesn’t have the same level of nightlife, shopping, or entertainment options as major metropolitan areas.

• Those looking for high-end shopping or diverse nightlife might need to travel to Philadelphia (1.5-hour drive) or Baltimore (2-hour drive) for more options.

4. Rapid Growth Leading to Rising Home Prices

• While still affordable compared to bigger cities, home prices in Lancaster have been steadily increasing due to high demand.

• Competition in the housing market can be tough, making it challenging for first-time buyers to find homes within their budget.

Frequently Asked Questions About Moving to Lancaster

Q: What are the best neighborhoods to live in?

• Downtown Lancaster – Great for young professionals who enjoy a walkable lifestyle, historic charm, and a vibrant arts scene.

• Manheim Township – Ideal for families, with top-rated schools and suburban conveniences.

• Lititz – A charming small town with a strong sense of community, often ranked as one of America’s best small towns.

• East Hempfield – A mix of suburban living and accessibility to major roads and shopping centers.

Q: What are the top things to do in Lancaster?

• Visit Lancaster Central Market, where you can find fresh produce, baked goods, and artisan crafts.

• Explore Amish Country, with guided tours starting at $25 per person.

• Hike or picnic at Chickies Rock Park, offering stunning views of the Susquehanna River.

• Enjoy live music and drinks at Tellus360 (cover charge varies, often around $10-$20).

• Take a hot air balloon ride over Lancaster County (starting at $250 per person).

Q: What are the best schools in the area?

• Lancaster County has excellent public and private schools. Manheim Township and Hempfield School Districts are among the highest-rated.

• For higher education, Franklin & Marshall College and Millersville University are well-regarded institutions.

Q: What are the biggest concerns about moving to Lancaster?

• Some areas still have challenges with poverty and crime, although they are improving.

• The housing market is becoming more competitive, with prices rising steadily.

• Winters can be unpredictable, and some may find the rural roads difficult to navigate in snow and ice.

Conclusion: Is Lancaster, PA the Right Move for You?

Lancaster, PA, is a fantastic place to live, offering a balance of affordability, culture, and strong community ties. However, like any location, it comes with its own set of challenges. Whether you're drawn to its thriving local businesses, excellent restaurants, or peaceful countryside, Lancaster has something to offer everyone. If you’re considering a move, working with a local real estate expert can help you navigate the market and find the perfect home for your needs..